A spate of recent developments signals potential trouble for organizations allowing unpaid internships, particularly profit-seeking entities. The kickoff was an April 2, 2010 New York Times piece, the tenor of which was that many such internships amount to illegal unpaid employment. The article quoted the U.S. Wage and Hour Division’s Deputy Administrator Nancy J. Leppink as saying, “If you’re a for-profit employer or you want to pursue an internship with a for-profit employer, there aren’t going to be many circumstances where you can have an internship and not be paid and still be in compliance with the law.”

This was followed by the April 5 release of a similarly-toned report from the labor-side Economic Policy Institute. And, on April 7, California’s Division of Labor Standards Enforcement issued a letter opinion outlining its views about under what circumstances these relationships are permitted by that state’s laws.

Then last week, the U.S. Wage and Hour Division released its Fact Sheet No. 71 in which it listed six criteria that it said “must” be applied, ”all” of which must be met, in order for an unpaid internship not to violate the federal Fair Labor Standards Act where for-profit, private-sector organizations are concerned. These factors, which have not been the subject of notice-and-comment rulemaking, are (with some editing):

•  The internship is similar to training given in an educational environment, even if it includes actual operation of the employer’s facilities,

•  The internship is for the intern’s benefit;

•  The intern does not displace regular employees but instead works under the existing staff’s close supervision;

•  The employer derives no immediate advantage from the intern’s activities, and its operations might occasionally actually be impeded;

•  The intern is not necessarily entitled to a job at the internship’s end; and

•  The employer and the intern understand that the intern is not entitled to wages for the time spent in the internship.

Whether public-sector and non-profit internships will be viewed with skepticism similar to that running through this document remains to be seen (although the Fact Sheet implies that they might not be).  The Wage and Hour Division says that it is “reviewing the need for additional guidance” in these areas.  Even those sectors should therefore proceed with caution.

Maybe all of this is remarkable happenstance. Or maybe instead it reveals a focused coordination of efforts aimed at coming enforcement initiatives.  Either way, any for-profit organization that is still willing to take on unpaid internships should structure and handle them so as to maximize the chances that they will be found not to create employment relationships for wage-hour purposes.

Do you have the right handyman business insurance?

Share on Facebook

Related posts:

1. Handyman Coincidental or Coordinated? Unpaid Internships Drawing Lots Of Attention (Updated 05/25/10) A spate of recent developments signals potential trouble for organizations allowing unpaid internships, particularly profit-seeking entities. The kickoff was an April 2, 2010 New York Times piece, the tenor of which was that many such internships amount to illegal unpaid employment.  The article quoted the U.S. Wage and Hour Division’s Deputy Administrator Nancy J. Leppink [...]...
2. Saudi Arabia adopts sustainability as a fundamental focus in the Kingdom’s recent boom in construction projects Saudi Arabia adopts sustainability as a fundamental focus in the Kingdom's recent boom in construction projects...
3. Handyman Insurance: USDOL Targeting H-1B Pay/Benefits Compliance The US Labor Department is aggressively investigating compliance with the wage-rate and benefits commitments employers must make in an H-1B Labor Condition Application (LCA). These investigations are usually triggered when an H-1B employee complains that the employer failed to pay the LCA wage. The H-1B program allows foreign nationals to work in the US in [...]...
4. What Is The “Youth Minimum Wage”? We’ve had inquiries recently about whether the federal Fair Labor Standards Act allows employers to pay less than its $7.25-per-hour minimum wage to certain younger workers.  While there is such an exception, it is limited in important ways. The FLSA’s so-called “Opportunity Wage” provision allows an employer to pay a worker who is under 20 [...]...
5. HANDYMAN LEGISLATIVE ALERT: Bills Threaten More FLSA Penalties Lurking in Senate and House “misclassification” bills are expansive changes in the Fair Labor Standards Act’s civil money penalties.  The impact of these revisions would extend far beyond U.S. Labor Department investigations involving independent-contractor status. Today, the FLSA permits DOL to impose a civil penalty of up to $1,100 for each violation of the minimum-wage [...]...
6. Handyman Comply Or Else, But Don’t Ask For Help Tough talk and other recent developments could reveal an increasingly adversarial, “gotcha” approach to FLSA enforcement by the U.S. Wage and Hour Division.  A prior post covered both the We Can Help initiative and other intensified U.S. Labor Department enforcement measures. The Division also announced this week that, as part of a broader DOL policy, it [...]...
7. Handyman Caution Called For In Documenting Compliance Efforts Handyman Caution Called For In Documenting Compliance Efforts...
8. Handyman New Sheriff, Launches FLSA Enforcement Program U.S. Labor Secretary Solis has announced the We Can Help program, which is designed in part to encourage reports of alleged Fair Labor Standards Act non-compliance. Solis declared that there is "a new sheriff in town" and outlined steps such as launching an advertising campaign; distributing videos, posters, and booklets; introducing theme-focused items on the Labor Department's website; providing a hotline; and working through community activists and others....
9. Handyman Nature Of DOLs “Right To Know” Remains Largely Unknown The U.S. Labor Department’s most-recent regulatory agenda now targets April 2011 for the release of a proposed rule that DOL says is intended to, among other things, “update [federal Fair Labor Standards Act] recordkeeping requirements to foster more openness and transparency in demonstrating employers’ compliance with applicable requirements to their workers, to better ensure compliance [...]...
10. Handyman Quick Quiz Answer: Bonus Based Upon Company’s Annual Performance The answer to our November 4 Quick Quiz is “Yes”:  Fair Labor Standards Act overtime must indeed be figured on the kind of bonus we described.  In fact, the U.S. Wage and Hour Division’s Office of Enforcement Policy (“OEP”) took this position with respect to such a bonus in a May 2006 opinion letter. Under [...]...
11. Be On Guard For Looming FLSA Recordkeeping Changes The U.S. Labor Department has now provided additional, disquieting insight into its “Plan, Prevent, Protect” program that we first reported on in our April 30 post.  Part of DOL’s Spring Regulatory Agenda 2010 announces an intention to issue a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (“NPRM”) proposing significant amendments to the FLSA recordkeeping regulations. ** Handyman Insurance [...]...
12. Handyman Employer Beware: Employees Might Be Keeping Secret Records At DOL’s Recommendation Handyman Employer Beware: Employees Might Be Keeping Secret Records At DOL’s Recommendation — Tucked away in a recent U.S. Labor Department e-newsletter was the announcement of a new “Work Hours Calendar.”  It is a time-tracking document that the Wage and Hour Division urges workers to maintain separately from the employer’s official records.  According to the [...]...
13. Handyman Care In Drafting Pay Documents Is Essential Handyman Care In Drafting Pay Documents Is Essential: In all her 20 years in human resources, Janice has never seen anything like it.  Bigtime Electronics fired its Production Manager Fred Smith last week, and now his lawyer has sent Janice a letter demanding that Fred be paid more than $20,000 for overtime worked during his [...]...
14. Handyman, DOL To Focus Upon Top-Down, Industry Compliance Fisher & Phillips participated last week in a Washington, D.C. “Stakeholder Forum” conducted by the U.S. Labor Department’s Wage and Hour Division.  A recurring theme during this session was the Division’s focus upon industry- and sector-wide compliance initiatives under the federal Fair Labor Standards Act. The Division is particularly concerned about what it calls “fissured” [...]...
15. Be Careful About Signing Official Back-Wage Summaries When U.S. Wage and Hour Division investigators conclude that back-wages are due under the federal Fair Labor Standards Act, at some point they present the employer with a completed Form WH-56, called a “Summary of Unpaid Wages”.  This document reflects a variety of information, including the names of each individual the investigator believes should receive [...]...