HANDYMAN INSURANCE .com

INSURANCE TOOLS FOR THE HANDYMAN AND SMALL BUSINESS CONTRACTOR

 



Indiana Court Decision Has Insurance Implications for Parents and Insurance Companies

Friday, Aug. 10th 2012 3:59 PM

 

At the end of June, an Indiana U.S. district court ruled that a father’s repeated verbal warnings to his daughter about not letting anyone else drive her car were strong enough to allow his insurer to deny coverage for an accident that occurred while her boyfriend was driving. The case has implications for insurers as well as parents who want to control their liability when their children are in possession of their insured car.

The case was brought by Allstate Insurance against the Agoston family (which owned the car that was insured by Allstate), Michael Hahn (the boyfriend of Sarah Agoston who ended up causing the crash), and Samantha Smythe (who was riding in the car at the time of the accident and was “seriously injured”). The court ruled Allstate did not have to pay for damages caused in the accident because Hahn was at the wheel, not one of the insured drivers under the policy.

Case Background

More than three years before the accident, when Sarah Agoston turned 16 and started driving, her father, Vincent Agoston, repeatedly warned her that she was to allow no one else to drive their cars. Court documents indicate that he reminded her of this restriction repeatedly.

But when Sarah started dating Hahn, who lacked a valid license, he would continually insist on driving, and she eventually gave in, allowing him to drive the car. She did this without letting her parents know about the existence of Hahn, much less the fact that she was allowing him to drive the car. After a party at Sarah’s apartment one night in March 2010, she gave in again and let him drive the car with she and Smythe riding as passengers. The court documents say that the group of friends at Sarah’s apartment that night had consumed alcohol and pills, and while on the way to a friend’s house, Hahn crashed the car. The accident was serious, with Hahn having to be transported by lifeline to the hospital.

Smythe ended up seeking compensation from Hahn, the Agostons, and American Commerce Insurance for her medical expenses. (The court documents do not explain who was insured by American Commerce, however.) And at the same time, Allstate filed this case, arguing that it did not have to provide compensation since Hahn was the one in the driver’s seat. Ultimately, the court agreed.

Why the Accident Was Not Covered

Whether someone else who drives your car will be covered by your insurance policy is one of the most common auto insurance claims questions that get asked. And, usually, they would be covered as long as they had your permission. But since Sarah’s parents had explicitly restricted her ability to let others drive the car, that general principle did not apply in this case, the court said. In the court’s decision, it cited a handful of cases in which coverage was negated because individuals who had borrowed a car under specific restrictions had lent the car out in spite of those restrictions. Sarah, after all, wasn’t the actual policyholder; her parents were.

Sarah’s parents “expressly prohibited anyone but Sarah from driving the vehicle, and Sarah had been continually reminded of this,” the court wrote. “Because of this restriction, Sarah herself did not have the right to grant anyone else permission to use the vehicle.”

When addressing the argument submitted by Smythe that Allstate had to cover the accident because Sarah’s parents had not listed Hahn as an excluded driver, the court said that her parents had made the rule so clear that it was “not necessary to explicitly list excluded drivers in the policy to make this restriction effective.”

This is only one case, though, and other incidents may have crucial details that affect who is covered. When you’re unsure, it’s always best to contact your insurer and go over who’d be covered in the event of an accident.

Posted by Handyman Insurance | in Handyman Insurance | No Comments »

 

 

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

best handyman insurance quotes offering low cost monthly rates Find the Best Insurance

Handyman insurance quotes is available on a state by state basis in Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Dist of Columbia, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia, Wisconsin, Wyoming. Find the best Handyman insurance quotes from some of the finest and solid insurance companies who compare liability coverages based upon your own personal choices.
Business insurance quotes Handyman Quotes

Business insurance quotes vary according to the state your business is in so you need to keep this mind when shopping for insurance.
Low Monthly Handyman QuotesLow Monthly Quotes

Your contractors license classification provides the insurance company the amount of risk and claims exposure you may incur as a result of your business.
Online Handyman Quotes

How many years of experience in the licensed classification influences your final business insurance quote.

Handyman Insurance

Insurance might not be the first thing someone thinks about when running a business, but it should be an important consideration.   Handyman insurance is another requirement if you are thinking about starting a handyman business.  This website provides important insurance information on Handyman Insurance Coverage and quotes.

Handyman Insurance Coverage

Handyman insurance includes several types of coverage; each one offers a specific kind of protection for your business.  

(Handyman Insurance ) Commercial Auto: Covers a business's owned, no owned, and hired autos against liability and physical damage losses. 

Handyman Workers Compensation:  If your business as a Handyman employs any staff (including part-time, trainees or sub-contractors), Employers liability insurance cover is a legal requirement.  Employers liability insurance provides protection against your legal liabilities to pay compensation in respect of injury sustained by your employees in the course of your business as a Handyman.  (Handyman Insurance) Workers Compensation: Provides coverage for an employer's responsibility in the event of a work-related injury or illness.   Employers Liability Insurance for handyman work: This type of insurance would cover payment of legal fees and damages in the event that an employee was injured or killed while doing work for you. 

Tradesman Insurance for handymen: This is a package of several different kinds of cover for handymen, making up one policy that meets all your insurance needs.

Public Liability Insurance for handyman work: This type of insurance would cover you if your business activities caused injury or death to a member of the public.

Handyman General Liability - Commercial jobs will require you to have general liability coverage of $1,000,000 to $2,000,000 prior to being hired (not to mention that you protect your assets if something goes wrong on the job).

Products liability insurance for Handymen - Products liability insurance provides protection against your legal liability, compensation costs and expenses following injury or damage by goods that you have sold, supplied, repaired, tested or delivered in connection with your business as a Handyman.  Products Liability insurance for Handymen at 1,000,000 with the option to increase to 2,000,000 up to 5,000,000 or more.  Public Liability insurance cover provides protection against your legal liability for injury to third parties and damage to their property in connection with your business as a Handyman.

Professional Indemnity Insurance for handyman work: This covers you against any mistakes you might make  including bad advice you or your staff might give  that ends up costing your clients money, and leading them to take legal action against you.

(Handyman Insurance ) Umbrella Coverage: A broader form of coverage that extends the limits of liability found in a base policy form. 

Income Protection Insurance - If the essential person should be unable to work for a period of time, this handyman insurance helps to cover the loss of business as a result of the illness or injury.  Having sufficient income protection insurance is also a worth while consideration, if you were to fall off a step ladder or hurt your back and couldnt work, accident, sickness and unemployment insurance could help you to pay for some of your monthly bills in the event of you not being able to work.

The Handyman Insurance Program gives our policyholder comprehensive coverage for their handyman businesses, and the program is designed for Handymen who: Are hired to do a variety of miscellaneous work that would be found in a residential household environment;

Please note that standard home owner's insurance will most likely not cover business assets, and may VOID your home insurance coverage.  If your business is home-based, do you need more liability coverage than your home insurance policy covers. 

The Handyman program gives our policyholder comprehensive coverage for their handyman businesses, and the program is designed for Handymen.

Handyman Insurance Quotes

Find information on insurance companies and agents, rate quotes and comparisons, insurance buying tips, claims filing information and much more. Find the best Handyman insurance quotes liability commercial and small Handyman companies offering affordable monthly payment options for your handyman business and the self-employed.  Find the best Handyman insurance quotes from some of the finest and solid insurance companies who compare liability coverages based upon your own personal choices.  Get online quotes for handyman insurance now.  And it can help you save money on your handyman insurance without compromising on the level of cover you need.  The Handyman tradesman insurance policy has been crafted to cover all your Handyman insurance needs at the most competitive price.

 

A reminder this is not an attempt to describe the product coverage and its' contents but merely used as a sales tool for the purpose of product illustration. The website and its' owners cannot make recommendations as to whether any illustrated product may meet the users' particular needs. Therefore, the suitability of the product is the final determination of the user of this website. The use of this website is acceptance of the sites' privacy statement. Coverage is not in effect until an application is signed, transmitted, payment received and approved by the underwriting company unless otherwise specifically stated. A physical and/or background inspection may be done to verify the information provided. The quote(s) will be based up on the underwriting information you supplied and the quote(s) is/are subject to change upon inspection and review by the underwriting company. The underwriting company reserves the right to determine the final coverage, premium and acceptability. Commercial use by others is prohibited by law. No portion of any news or information from this website may be photocopied, faxed, mailed, distributed, transmitted, published, broadcasted, duplicated, or re-distributed in any manner for any purpose without prior written authorization of its' owner.